Compare Yacht Insurance: Hull, P&I & Charter Cover
Written by the Yacht Cover Brokers editorial team · reviewed by Anton Kuznetsov, founder
When you compare yacht insurance, you are not shopping for a commodity. The difference between a policy that responds cleanly and one that leaves you arguing a claim in Antibes or Antigua often comes down to clause wording, trading limits, and whether your broker asked the right questions before binding. This page sets out what to look for across hull, P&I, crew and charter cover — and what to bring to us so we can place the right structure for your vessel and programme.
What You Are Actually Comparing: Policy Structure Before Premium
Most yacht owners start by comparing premiums. The more productive starting point is comparing what each policy actually covers and, critically, what it excludes. A hull policy written on Institute Hull Clauses (IHC) terms offers a materially different scope of cover to one written on a bespoke yacht wording — and neither is automatically superior. What matters is whether the wording matches your vessel's trading pattern, age, construction, and how you use her.
The Inchmaree clause is a useful litmus test. It extends hull cover to losses caused by latent defect in hull or machinery, negligence of crew, and similar perils that a basic marine policy would not pick up. If your policy does not include it, a mechanical failure that causes a flooding casualty may fall outside cover. Ask your broker to confirm whether Inchmaree is incorporated and whether any sub-limits apply.
Sue-and-labour provisions matter equally. These oblige you to take reasonable steps to minimise a loss — and entitle you to recover those costs from underwriters even if the underlying claim is not ultimately paid. If your vessel grounds off St Maarten and you engage salvors to prevent further damage, sue-and-labour should respond to those costs. Confirm the clause is present and that it is not capped at a level that would leave you exposed on a large salvage operation.
Hull Cover: Trading Limits, Lay-Up and the Mediterranean / Caribbean / Gulf Triangle
Your hull policy will define a trading area, and anything outside it is uninsured. If you cruise the Western Mediterranean from Palma in summer, position to Antigua for the winter season, and keep the vessel in Dubai during the refit period, you need a policy whose geographic scope covers all three — not one written for European waters only with a mid-term extension bolted on each time you cross an ocean.
War and piracy exclusions are standard in hull policies, but the mechanism for buying back cover differs. The Joint War Committee (JWC) publishes a Listed Areas schedule that identifies high-risk zones. If your passage plan takes you through the Red Sea, the Gulf of Aden, or anywhere near Bab-el-Mandeb, you will need a separate war risk endorsement, and the additional premium is calculated on the vessel's agreed value and the duration of the transit. This is not a discretionary add-on — it is a condition of cover for those waters.
Lay-up arrangements affect your premium and your obligations. If your vessel is laid up out of class — for example, during an extended refit in a Turkish yard — underwriters may apply a different deductible structure or require a survey before cover resumes. Agree the lay-up terms in writing before the vessel goes ashore, not after.
P&I Cover and the LLMC: Why Your Liability Limit Is Not the Ceiling You Think It Is
Third-party liability for a yacht is not capped at your hull value. A collision that damages a superyacht berth in Antibes, injures crew on a neighbouring vessel, or causes pollution in a marina can generate claims that dwarf the value of your own boat. Your P&I cover — whether written as a standalone policy or as a section of a combined yacht policy — needs to be sized against the realistic worst-case exposure for your vessel and cruising grounds.
The Convention on Limitation of Liability for Maritime Claims (LLMC) provides a statutory framework that allows shipowners, including yacht owners, to limit their liability to a figure calculated by reference to the vessel's gross tonnage, expressed in Special Drawing Rights (SDRs). The 1996 Protocol sets the applicable limits for most European jurisdictions. However, limitation is not automatic — it must be claimed, it can be broken if the claimant proves the loss resulted from your personal act or omission with intent or reckless disregard, and it does not apply in all jurisdictions. The Caribbean and Gulf states do not all give effect to the LLMC in the same way. Do not treat the convention as a substitute for adequate P&I limits.
If you operate under a charter contract — whether bareboat or crewed — your charter agreement will almost certainly impose minimum P&I limits and may require you to name the charterer or management company as an additional insured. Review the contract before renewal, not after a claim reveals a gap.
Charter and Commercial Use: What Changes When You Take a Fee
A private pleasure policy does not respond to losses arising from commercial charter operations. If you take a fee — even informally, even to cover running costs — and your policy is written on a private use basis, you may find yourself without cover at the moment you need it most. The distinction between private and commercial use is one of the most common sources of coverage disputes in yacht claims.
Charter operators need a policy that explicitly covers commercial use, addresses the liability exposure to paying guests, and deals with the crew's position under the Maritime Labour Convention (MLC 2006). MLC 2006 imposes financial security obligations in respect of crew repatriation, wages in the event of abandonment, and death and disability compensation. If your vessel is flagged in a jurisdiction that has ratified MLC 2006 — which includes most European flag states — you need to be able to demonstrate that financial security is in place. A specialist underwriter can provide the MLC certificate of financial security as part of your programme.
If you operate in the Mediterranean under a charter licence — whether a Greek HNTO licence, a Spanish charter permit, or a French pavillon — the local authority may require evidence of specific minimum liability limits before the licence is issued or renewed. We can provide the documentation underwriters issue for this purpose, but we need to know the flag state, the cruising area, and the charter structure before we approach the market.
- Confirm whether your policy is written on a private, semi-commercial or full commercial charter basis
- Check that paying guests are covered as third parties under your P&I section
- Verify MLC 2006 financial security is in place if your vessel carries professional crew
- Obtain the correct certificate of insurance for your charter licence jurisdiction before the season opens
- Ensure your crew's ENG-1 medicals and STCW certificates are current — underwriters may ask for confirmation at renewal
What to Bring to Us When You Want to Compare Quotes
Comparing yacht insurance meaningfully requires like-for-like information. If you approach three brokers with different information, you will receive three quotes that are not comparable. Bring the same submission to each conversation and you will be able to evaluate the differences in wording, limits and conditions rather than simply the premium.
We will need the following to approach specialist underwriters on your behalf and return a structured comparison rather than a single indicative figure.
- Vessel details: name, flag, year built, builder, LOA, construction material, current agreed value
- Classification society and class status, or confirmation the vessel is unclassed
- Trading area for the coming policy year, including any planned ocean passages or high-risk transits
- Intended use: private pleasure, bareboat charter, crewed charter, or mixed
- Crew details: skipper's qualifications, experience, and whether crew are employed or owner-operated
- Claims history for the past five years, including any incidents that did not result in a formal claim
- Copies of any existing policies, charter contracts, or management agreements that impose insurance obligations
Renewal Timing and What to Expect from the Market
Yacht insurance is an annual contract. Underwriters review your risk at each renewal, and the terms they offer reflect both your individual claims history and broader market conditions. If you have had a loss, expect underwriters to ask detailed questions about the cause and the remedial steps taken. If you have been claim-free, that record is an asset — make sure your broker presents it clearly rather than letting it disappear into a generic submission.
Approach renewal at least six to eight weeks before expiry. If your vessel is in a yard for refit, confirm with your broker whether the existing policy responds during the refit period and whether the yard's own marine liability cover is adequate for the work being undertaken. Yards in Turkey, Montenegro, and the Canaries vary considerably in the scope of their own insurance, and a gap between your hull cover and the yard's liability can leave you exposed to an uninsured loss.
If you are switching brokers or markets at renewal, request a full copy of your expiring policy wording — not just the schedule — before the new policy is bound. Comparing a schedule to a schedule tells you the premium and the headline limits. Comparing the full wording tells you whether the new policy is genuinely equivalent or whether it has narrower exclusions, higher deductibles in specific circumstances, or different sue-and-labour provisions.
Frequently asked questions
- Do I need separate war risk cover if I am only cruising the Mediterranean?
- For most Western Mediterranean cruising — Palma, Antibes, the Italian coast, Greece — your standard hull policy will include war risk cover automatically, subject to the JWC Listed Areas schedule. The areas that require a separate endorsement are those on the JWC list, which currently includes parts of the Red Sea, the Gulf of Aden, and certain other high-risk zones. If your passage plan takes you anywhere near those waters, speak to us before you depart. The endorsement needs to be in place before the transit, not after.
- What happens if I charter my yacht without telling my insurer?
- Your policy will almost certainly be voidable from inception if you take charter fees under a policy written for private use only. In practice, this means that if a loss occurs during a charter period, underwriters can decline the claim and potentially recover any payments already made. The fix is straightforward — tell us before the first charter, not after. The additional premium for commercial use is a fraction of the exposure you carry by operating without the correct cover in place.
- How does the LLMC affect my liability exposure as a yacht owner?
- The LLMC allows you to limit your liability to a figure based on your vessel's gross tonnage, expressed in SDRs under the 1996 Protocol. For a typical sailing or motor yacht, that limit may be lower than the actual damages claimed in a serious collision or pollution incident. Limitation can also be broken if a claimant proves the loss resulted from your personal act or omission committed with intent to cause such loss, or recklessly and with knowledge that such loss would probably result. Your P&I cover should be sized to sit above the LLMC limit, not below it, and should include the cost of defending a limitation action.
- What do you need from me to start comparing quotes?
- The essentials are: vessel name, flag, year built, LOA, construction, agreed value, class status, intended trading area, use (private or charter), skipper qualifications, and five years' claims history. If you have an existing policy, send us the full wording rather than just the schedule. The more complete your submission, the more accurate and comparable the quotes we return will be.
- How long does it take to bind cover?
- For a straightforward private yacht with a clean claims history and standard trading area, we can typically return indicative terms within 48 hours of receiving a complete submission and bind cover the same day you confirm. More complex risks — large motor yachts, commercial charter operations, vessels with recent claims, or unusual trading areas — take longer because we need to approach specialist underwriters with a detailed presentation. Allow five to seven working days for a complex placement, and do not leave renewal to the last week before expiry.
- Does my policy cover the crew's medical and repatriation costs?
- It depends on how your policy is structured. A private yacht policy may include some crew liability cover, but it is unlikely to provide the full financial security required under MLC 2006 for vessels with employed professional crew. MLC 2006 requires flag-state-approved financial security for repatriation, wages in the event of abandonment, and death and disability compensation. If your vessel is flagged in a ratifying state and you carry professional crew, you need a specific MLC certificate of financial security — this is a separate instrument from your hull or P&I policy and needs to be arranged deliberately, not assumed to be included.
Ready to compare yacht insurance on a like-for-like basis? Send us your vessel details and trading plan and we will return a structured comparison of hull, P&I, crew and charter options from specialist underwriters — with a clear explanation of where the policies differ, not just what they cost.